Skip to main content

Power BI

New

Make PBI desktop the one-stop IDE for all of Power BI

Vote (6) Share
Josh Turnbull's profile image

Josh Turnbull on 01 Nov 2022 13:40:07

Developing locally is far better than browser based editing for all the usual reasons - limited functionality, session timeouts and connectivity issues, lack of source control or any visibility of your artifact. Unfortuantely, there are still too many artifacts that must be edited in browser, e.g. dataflows and datamarts. In the modern data world, these things aren't isolated units but part of much bigger interconnected solutions, but the current state of development tools does not reflect this. In particular it's a big problem to e.g. develop dataflows with the appropriate change governance for something that is intended to be a fairly upstream entity - the export json function doesn't do much good when you can't import a json file to change an existing dataflow.


PBI desktop has the potential for being a one-stop IDE for all Power BI development, but currently it only has the ability to output pbix/pbit files that necessarily contain both a dataset and report. If reworked as an IDE it could:


  • Allow for development of dataflows and datamarts locally
  • Allow developers to maintain an entire solution containing many related artifacts
  • Integrate with source control, with potential for regression testing and CI/CD pipelines (e.g. ALM toolkit scripts in the same solution)
  • Reuse of M/DAX libraries across an enterprise or application suite
  • Integration with visual development projects
  • Treating datasets and reports as separate objects, as Microsoft advise we develop anyway!


Alternatively, a Power BI extension in visual studio/visual studio code would be great, and allow us to create solutions that link in with other parts of a data stack (e.g. a SQL data warehouse) much easier.

Comments (1)
Josh Turnbull's profile image Profile Picture

Olivier Travers on 10 Jan 2023 22:48:26

RE: Make PBI desktop the one-stop IDE for all of Power BI

This makes way too much sense for Microsoft to do it, if we're being realistic, when datasets are not even well supported. Here's the current state of Power BI Desktop and MS BI dev tools more generally:Power Query UI is lagging PQ Online by about two years. Microsoft's answer: "oh, sorry, Power Query is a different team".Power BI Desktop has antiquated UI design that can hardly be called an IDE: horrible DAX formula bar, single window design that doesn't take into account modern wide screens / multi monitor; PQ editor doesn't even have an undo, etc.Power BI Premium features such as OLS, Partitions, Perspectives etc. are not supported in Power BI Desktop.Power BI Premium XMLA endpoint is not fully supported in SSMS.SSDT / Analysis Services Projects extension is buggy abandonware that's not even been released in GA for VS 2022.I could go on and on, these problems are well known and have been plaguing the platform for years. Microsoft's answer: sucks to be you, just install DAX Studio and Tabular Editor. But told in a very empathetic tone, because this is the New Microsoft.We're seeing the current incremental approach with a drip of small monthly tweaks reaching its limits, when Power BI Desktop is now seriously starting to show its age and poor fit for enterprise BI.